Poisonous Plants and Their Beneficial Lookalikes
When you’re foraging or even just out enjoying nature, it’s easy to get a little too confident about what’s growing around you. After all, how dangerous can a plant really be? The answer: very. Especially if you don’t know exactly what you’re looking at. Some of the most poisonous plants in North America grow right along hiking trails, ditches, and pastures, often mimicking harmless plants that many foragers rely on.
Today, we’re diving into some of the most dangerous plants and their beneficial herbal lookalikes, plus how to properly identify them so you can stay safe. This is not a place to guess. The best way to stay safe is to use multiple sources to confirm what you’re looking at. I personally use the Peterson Field Guides and the Picture This app on my phone whenever I forage. Whatever source you use, be sure the pictures and the information are crystal clear. Hand-drawn or black and white pictures of wild plants may be pretty, but they don’t give you a clear answer. And safety is nothing to play with.
Let’s get into five of the more dangerous wild plants and their safe and beneficial lookalikes.
Poison Hemlock vs. Queen Anne’s Lace
Poison Hemlock is one of the most dangerous and poisonous plants in the United States. It looks a lot like Queen Anne’s Lace (wild carrot), but don’t be fooled.
-
Hemlock has smooth, hollow stems with purple blotches and streaks on the stems. When hemlock is very young, it can be very difficult to see the purple coloration until it gets bigger, so don’t go by that identifying marker alone. Pay close attention to the pattern of the leaves as well. It doesn’t smell like carrot, more like mouse urine, honestly.
-
Queen Anne’s Lace has hairy stems, smells like carrots, and is a common edible plant used for teas and herbal remedies.
Toxic Plant: Poison Hemlock (Conium maculatum)
Dangers (all parts of the plant are toxic):
-
Contains toxic alkaloids that can cause respiratory failure and death.
-
Seizures
-
Vomiting
-
Racing Heartbeat/ Palpitations
-
Skin contact may lead to a severe allergic reaction or irritation.
Herbal Lookalike: Queen Anne’s Lace (Daucus carota) AKA wild carrot
Herbal Properties and Benefits:
- Diuretic and digestive aid
-
Supports kidney and urinary health
-
Seeds traditionally used for birth control (not recommended without guidance)
-
Antibacterial and antifungal properties
Key Differences:
-
Poison Hemlock has smooth stems with purple blotches and no carrot scent.
-
Queen Anne’s Lace has hairy stems and smells like carrots.
Key tip: When in doubt, don’t touch it. If it’s smooth and blotchy, back away. Long sleeves and gloves are a good idea if you have to be near.
Wild Parsnip vs. Yarrow
Wild Parsnip might not be deadly, but it causes severe burns and skin irritation when its sap reacts with sunlight. It’s a condition called phytophotodermatitis.
Yarrow and Wild Parsnip don’t look almost identical the way our first two examples do, but when wild parsnip is just starting to flower, it can resemble yellow yarrow. Yarrow typically blooms white, but it can be yellow. When it is, it grows in similar small blossom clusters, like young wild parsnip does. But again, the leaf and stem will give you your positive identification.
-
Wild Parsnip has yellow flowers in an umbel shape and wider, smooth, grooved stems.
-
Yarrow has fern-like leaves, small white flowers, but other colors are possible too, and is used as an anti-inflammatory, wound healer, and fever reducer.
Toxic Plant: Wild Parsnip (Pastinaca sativa)
Dangers:
- Causes phytophotodermatitis: it can cause severe skin blisters and burns when exposed to sunlight. This process can take a day or so to happen.
-
Blistering, rash, burning, itching, and long-term skin discoloration and scarring.
Herbal Lookalike: Yarrow (Achillea millefolium)
Herbal Properties and Benefits:
- Anti-inflammatory and wound-healing
-
Stops bleeding from cuts and scrapes
-
Digestive aid and antispasmodic
-
Supports the immune system and reduces fevers
Key Differences:
-
Wild Parsnip has yellow flowers and smooth stems.
-
Yarrow has white (sometimes pink) flower clusters and feathery leaves.
Key tip: If you’re out in late spring to early summer, keep your eye on the leaf shape and flower structure. Early identification is pretty simple to make with these two.
False Morels vs. True Morels
This one isn’t an herb, but if you’re in the Midwest, you know how popular morel season is. Because of that, and the fact that medicinal mushrooms and herbalism work so well together, I thought I’d add this one to the list. False Morels are toxic mushrooms that can cause abdominal pain, severe illness, and even death.
-
True Morels have a hollow stem and cap. The entire mushroom is hollow when sliced open.
-
False Morels look brainy or lobed and are often not completely hollow.
Toxic Plant: False Morels
Dangers:
- Contains gyromitrin, a toxin that causes vomiting, diarrhea, dizziness, and liver damage
-
In some cases, ingestion is fatal
Herbal Lookalike: True Morels (Morchella)
Herbal Properties and Benefits:
- Rich in antioxidants and vitamin D
-
Supports immune health
-
High in protein and fiber
-
Culinary delicacy with adaptogenic properties
Key Differences:
-
True Morels are completely hollow inside.
-
False Morels are not uniformly hollow and appear lobed or wrinkled.
Key tip: If you find a mushroom and aren’t 100% sure it’s a true morel, don’t eat it. Wild mushrooms without positive identification are not something you want to mess with.
Poison Ivy vs. Wild Black Raspberry
It sounds like an easy one, but when vining leaves of poison ivy grow next to a thorny bramble, people can get confused. Especially when both plants are younger.
-
Poison Ivy has three compound leaves with a glossy finish and often grows in moist areas and on forest floors. The center leaf typically has a longer stem than the other two, and the leaves are smooth.
-
Wild Black Raspberry has compound leaves too, but look for the arching canes, more textured leaves and even leaves, and thorns on the stems and canes. These are completely safe and delicious once they’re ripe.
Toxic Plant: Poison Ivy (Toxicodendron radicans)
Dangers:
- Causes intense itching, rash, and blistering due to urushiol oil
-
Only those with an allergy to poison ivy will have a reaction
-
Allergic reaction can spread via tools, pets, or clothing
Herbal Lookalike: Wild Black Raspberry (Rubus occidentalis)
Herbal Properties and Benefits:
-
Rich in vitamin C and antioxidants
-
Supports the immune system and heart health
-
Leaves can be used in herbal teas for digestive upset and sore throats
Key Differences:
-
Poison Ivy has shiny leaves in groups of three, without thorns.
-
Wild Black Raspberry has prickly canes and dull, green compound leaves.
Key tip: Learn the saying, “Leaves of three, let it be”, but then learn more. Know how parts of the plant differ in the bark, thorns, and growing patterns.
Horse Nettle vs. Stinging Nettle
This one surprises a lot of people. There are many plants that have the name “nettle” in their names, but they’re not TRUE nettles. In fact, there are only about 6 varieties of true nettles in North America. Horse Nettle is a nightshade and is toxic. Stinging Nettle is one of the most useful plants out there.
-
Horse Nettle has spiny leaves instead of stinging hairs, yellow fruits, and is in the nightshade family. It can cause abdominal pain, vomiting, and more.
-
Stinging Nettle has tiny hair-like spines that cause a sting on contact, but lose their sting when dried or cooked. It’s rich in vitamins and minerals and used for everything from joint pain to digestive issues, and all things inflamed. It does not produce fruit.
Toxic Plant: Horse Nettle (Solanum carolinense)
Dangers:
- Contains solanine, which causes abdominal pain, vomiting, and difficulty breathing
-
Unripe fruits are especially toxic
Herbal Lookalike: Stinging Nettle (Urtica dioica)
Herbal Properties and Benefits:
- Anti-inflammatory and high in minerals like iron and calcium
-
Supports joint health and urinary function
-
Can be used for allergies, eczema, and anemia
-
Strengthens hair, nails, and skin
Key Differences:
-
Horse Nettle has star-shaped purple flowers and yellow berries.
-
Stinging Nettle has jagged leaves with tiny hairs that sting but become harmless when dried or cooked.
Key tip: Know the difference in plant parts, especially the presence of unripe fruits on horse nettle.
About Foraging Safety
Don’t assume. Proper identification is everything. Use multiple sources. Learn the leaf shape, growth pattern, flower color, and plant parts. Get familiar with both wild edibles and toxic plants. And don’t forget to wear protective clothing like long sleeves and gloves if you’re foraging in unknown areas.
For emergencies, contact Poison Control or consult your local wildlife service or U.S. Fish and Wildlife office. Keep plenty of water and herbal remedies like plantain salve handy for skin irritation.
If you come in contact with a toxic plant, wash the area with soap and water as soon as possible to remove the oils from your skin and minimize the reaction. If you ingest anything on this list, seek emergency medical treatment IMMEDIATELY.
We live in a world where harmless look-alikes grow right beside the most dangerous plants in nature. Respect that. And let that respect guide how you approach every patch of green you meet.
Stay curious, stay cautious, and keep learning.
Don't miss a thing!
New herbal education and recipes delivered to your inbox.
We hate SPAM. We will never sell your information, for any reason.
